As we watched the replay of the potential final out of Andres Galarraga’s possible perfect game with our jaws on the ground let’s take notice that although Jim Joyce did make the wrong call we have to ask another question. Why did Miguel Cabrera go into the hole for the grounder when it was clearly the second basemen’s play to make?
The very poor umpire call should never have been an issue and this game would have given MLB it’s first ever 3 perfect game season and it’s only June. The real surprise is this kid Galarraga took it like a man and never once mentioned the call or Joyce as the culprit. Maybe he was lucky to even get that far because there was a play earlier in the 9th inning where Mark Grudzielanek hit the first pitch of the inning to deep left center and Detroit center fielder Austin Jackson made an unbelievable catch over his head to preserve the perfecto.
The call was horrendous and the perfect game along with the no-no went completely down the drain, but right when we are about to forget Roy Halladay’s perfect game (20th in MLB history) we can always talk about the one that got away.
D2B,
I say protest the game, have the call reviewed and give the kid his perfect game. Yes we are all humans and people screw up, we also give forgivness and second chances.
As I said in our movie the Bad News Bears, let them play, let them play!
In this case I say, reverse the call, reverse the call!!!!!
-BNB out
I say NO.. this game like many others are ruled by humans and human error is part of the game.. We dont need more replay we need better human decisions